My Info

Realtor

Natalie Poels

Shawano Office
105 S. Washington Street Shawano, WI 54166
Natalie Poels Profile Photo
My Bio

About Natalie Poels

Originally from Milwaukee, I moved to the Clintonville-Shawano area in 1994 and decided then and there that Shawano would be my home. Enjoying the beauty and recreation this area has to offer, it was easy for me to say – “Hello Lake Life!”

My previous careers have all been in sales and customer service until I took a few years off to renovate and remodel our 1920’s “fixer-upper”.  As my project was coming to an end, I went to work for a local Title Company as a Closing Coordinator, however, my love for houses and real estate started long before that. As someone who is continually doing projects to add value to my own home, I’ve always had an interest in following design styles, ongoing market trends, current home prices and their availability.

The decision to join Coldwell Banker was an easy one for me. This company strives to continually educate their agents and provides us with the tools needed to be successful. We have amazing agents here and their willingness to support one another in this industry is hard to match. Not to mention the 250 years of combined experience in our Shawano office alone! That level of experience means we can provide you with top-notch marketing, the newest listings, and a full-service experience to make sure you get the home you’re looking for and the price you expect.

Buying or selling a home is one of the most emotional and biggest financial decisions you’ll ever make, yet it can be complicated and stressful. It is my goal to make sure your experience is a positive one, helping people is something I truly enjoy. Let my outgoing demeanor, meticulous attention to detail, and background in the title industry help you negotiate and navigate through the process.

I am a full-time, full-service agent hoping to earn your trust and confidence. I look forward to representing you in the best possible way whether you're a first-time homebuyer or looking to sell your property. Contact me at (920) 737-7245 and thank you for considering me as YOUR real estate agent.

Testimonials

What my clients are saying

Shane B.

Natalie Poels was amazing! She has been honest, friendly & helped us every step of the way. Her up beat & enthusiam is what got our attention first. I would recommend her over & over again. She worked very hard for us. She is the best!

November 4, 2026
Josh S.

I worked with Natalie and she was awesome to work with. She made everything very easy and smooth, we couldn’t have asked for a better relator.

August 12, 2026
Jeffrey W.

You know, unfortunately for me it wasn’t a happy experience of why I was selling. I had gotten divorced. It was painful to even think about going back to the land. That’s where Natalie and Rachel were phenomenal. They helped me through it. They handled everything for me. I didn’t have to go back and relive the painful memory they met me. I couldn’t have asked for two better people to help me through a time like that they were phenomenal. I would recommend them time and time again. They became personal friends through the sale

August 1, 2026
Laurie M.

Natalie made the process easy and quick. I accepted an offer in two weeks after the property was listed and it was for quite a bit more than what the listing price was. I’m so glad that the sale was quick and easy instead of long, drawn out and complicated. I would definitely use Natalie for any future purchases or sales.

July 15, 2026
Renae R.

Natalie was nothing short of amazing. I think we're safe to say to call her a friend now, not just our realtor. Highly recommend her services!!!!

June 25, 2026
David

Natalie was wonderful! We saw her for many weekends this fall. Always had our best interests in mind. Very thankful for her!

December 3, 2025
Natalie Poels

Listings

$624,900
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
$ 96.14/sqftCommercialZoningActive
468 Liberty Drive, Wittenberg, WI 54499
MLS #: 50324384
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
$465,000
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
3bds 2ba1,872sqftActive
190 Cty Rd N Highway, Birnamwood, WI 54414
MLS #: 50331494
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
$375,000
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
0.70 acre lot$535,714/AcreActive
1624 Spirit Ridge Road, Keshena, WI 54135
MLS #: 50334954
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
$139,900
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
1bds 1ba560sqftPending
W5418 Sandy Drive, Shawano, WI 54166
MLS #: 50324312
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
$129,900
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
1.07 acre lot$121,402/AcreActive
N7108 W Lake Crest Drive, Shawano, WI 54166
MLS #: 50333648
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
$49,900
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
1.80 acre lot$27,722/AcreActive
E Lake Crest Drive, Shawano, WI 54166
MLS #: 50333105
Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $239,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    3bds 2ba1,512sqftClosed
    W4863 Hidden Pine Lane, Shawano, WI 54166
    MLS #: 50330579
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $22,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    0.55 acre lot$40,000/AcreClosed
    W575 Sunrise Way, Keshena, WI 54135
    MLS #: 50330986
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $39,900
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    1.30 acre lot$30,692/AcreClosed
    North Court, Shawano, WI 54166
    MLS #: 50326984
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $13,500
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    0.55 acre lot$24,545/AcreClosed
    N1260 Big Sky Road, Keshena, WI 54135
    MLS #: 50295489
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $249,900
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    4bds 2ba2,052sqftClosed
    143 N Washington Street, Bonduel, WI 54107
    MLS #: 50299598
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $339,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    2bds 2ba864sqftClosed
    N6292 Cattau Beach Drive, Shawano, WI 54166
    MLS #: 50302689
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $115,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    -bds-ba432sqftClosed
    N7116 W Lake Crest Drive, Shawano, WI 54166
    MLS #: 50321931
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
    $120,000
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
    2bds 1ba912sqftClosed
    7674 County Road V, Gillett, WI 54124
    MLS #: 50327477
    Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $22,000
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
      0.55 acre lot$40,000/AcreClosed
      W575 Sunrise Way, Keshena, WI 54135
      MLS #: 50330986
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $135,000
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
      2bds 2ba1,320sqftClosed
      112 E Hofman Street, Cecil, WI 54111
      MLS #: 50325400
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $294,500
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
      3bds 2ba1,940sqftClosed
      W6023 Lake Drive, Shawano, WI 54166
      MLS #: 50324890
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $159,900
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
      -Units$-/Unit1,536sqftClosed
      202 W State Street, Bonduel, WI 54107
      MLS #: 50302704
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $365,000
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
      2bds 2ba1,302sqftClosed
      1648 Balsam Court, Shawano, WI 54166
      MLS #: 50306335
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $424,500
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
      3bds 2ba1,664sqftClosed
      133 Thomas Avenue, Shawano, WI 54166
      MLS #: 50305748
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $259,000
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
      2bds 2ba1,192sqftClosed
      203 Channel Trace, Shawano, WI 54166
      MLS #: 50321391
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $365,000
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group Logo
      2bds 2ba1,302sqftClosed
      1648 Balsam Court, Shawano, WI 54166
      MLS #: 50306335
      Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
      $195,000
      REALTORS® Association of Northeast Wisconsin IDX Logo
      2bds 1ba832sqftClosed
      N7081 E Lake Crest Drive, Shawano, WI 54166
      MLS #: 50325688
      Jason Gerhard & Associates Real Estate
      $299,000
      REALTORS® Association of Northeast Wisconsin IDX Logo
      3bds 2ba1,840sqftClosed
      N5699 Maders Circle, Shawano, WI 54166
      MLS #: 50325340
      LIV Wisconsin Realty
      $425,000
      REALTORS® Association of Northeast Wisconsin IDX Logo
      3bds 3ba1,672sqftClosed
      N1468 South Branch Path, Keshena, WI 54135
      MLS #: 50298647
      RE/MAX North Winds Realty, LLC